Beef Brisket
$19.50+
Brisket brined 24 hours, smoked 12, and served with two sides.
“We found this little gem traveling from home to Cleveland. It is AMAZING!! we make it a point to stop and eat and it never disappoints!! The brisket is fabulous!”
Brisket
Smoked Brisket Sammie
$16.50+
Brisket sandwich with peppers, onions, Jack cheese, and a sauce choice.
“Delicious wings! Love the smoked brisket sammie!”
Beef Brisket Salad
$14.25+
A salad topped with brisket, served wet or dry as chosen.
“Just visited Sammy Sue's for the first time. It's a small town bar with big flavors on the menu. It was wing night on Thursday, so I obliged and got the traditional wings (smoked and fried), with spicy BBQ and spicy bleu cheese sauces. Both were excellent with just the right level of heat. If the wings are any indication to the quality of the rest of their menu, you can take my word for it, Sammy Sue's knows BBQ! Make it a priority to satisfy your next savory craving!”
Brisket Flatbread
$14.00+
Brisket flatbread is topped with peppers, sautéed onions, and Jack cheese.
“The meal was phenomenal brisket A1, pulled pork out of this world & finally the full rack of ribs my top 5 ever. I don’t rate top 1 only my 5 best. Unbelievable on all levels service atomosphere, readiness, & friendliness. Like an old bbq joint in Texas.”
Pulled Pork
Pulled Pork
$13.75+
Hand-pulled smoked pork is seasoned in-house and served with two sides.
“Great venue! Love the older bar/restaurant atmosphere. Pulled pork - out of this world! Hand made shoestring fries! Awesome home made BBQ chips with seasoning! If I lived in Dover, these chips would be my "crack"!!”
Pulled Pork Salad
$12.00+
A salad topped with pulled pork, served wet or dry as chosen.
“Loved it nine years ago when we had dinner there on our way back from Burr Oak. Loved it so much, we asked them to cater our wedding in Akron, OH. Loved it again tonight when we got some takeout on our way back from West Virginia. It’s sincerely the best BBQ and sides I’ve ever had.”
Pork Flatbread
$12.00+
Pulled pork, caramelized onions, and cheddar top this flatbread.
“Excellent BBQ, best fair fries I've ever had and delicious chilli. Very friendly staff. First time there and will definitely be back! Highly recommend.”
Mac-N-Piggy Boats
$10.00
Potato boats hold pulled pork, white cheddar mac, cheddar, and bacon.
“Had their bbq brisket wrap and it was delicious. Very tender and flavorful. Left full and happy.”
Ribs
Ribs
$9.25+
Choose BBQ or plain ribs, served with a kids' side and beverage.
“Always good! Best Ribs period.”
Smokey Sampler
$30.00+
Smoked wings, ribs, brisket, and pulled pork come with three sides.
“The food was fantastic! So many good things to pick from. We tried the smoky sampler platter. Great options when you can’t decide on one thing. We will definitely be making the trip back.”
Chicken
Rustic Chicken Flatbread
$13.00+
Smoked chicken flatbread with Jack cheese, bacon, and honey Dijon mayo.
“Great place for bbq! Highly recommend this place to anyone looking for great tasting bbq.”
Chicken Flatbread
$12.00+
Smoked chicken, buffalo chicken sauce, and cheddar top this flatbread.
“All of their barbeque is fantastic, the wings are the best around, the staff is friendly and on the ball, and the prices are reasonable! Couldn't ask for more!”
Sandwiches
Pulled Pork Sammie
$12.75+
Smoked pulled pork fills a sandwich topped with BBQ sauce and creamy slaw.
“This was our first time here. The food is amazing. Pulled pork sandwich and fries outstanding, very filling, husband got steak and kids got chicken tenders and grilled cheese, all of which they thoroughly enjoyed. Our server Tina was super nice and took very care of us. We will be back again and soon!!!”
BBQ Sandwich
$9.25+
Kids' BBQ sandwich comes with pulled pork, a pickle spear, side, and drink.
“As far as barbecue goes, you can't get much better. Everything we tried was outstanding! The service was prompt and friendly.”
Burgers
Mac-N-Cheeseburger
$15.00
A burger is topped with white cheddar mac and BBQ pulled pork.
“Best bbq in tuscarawas county.”
"Big T" Burger
$16.50
BBQ beef brisket, hot pepper cheese, and bacon top this burger.
“Amazing wings and bbq!”
